Smartphones running Windows Phone 7 OS soon join the millions of iPhone and Android phones, but do they stand a chance with consumers? Maybe, but apparently not with the critics.
By Daniel Ionescu, PCWorld
Oct 22, 2010 11:13 am
Windows Phone 7 Reviews Wiegh In: Too Little, Too LateThe first reviews of Microsoft’s new Windows Phone 7 are in. Smartphones running the new OS will soon join the millions of iPhone and Android phones, but do they stand a chance? Reviewers are sceptical about the immediate success of Windows Phone 7 devices, as they are missing too many features, but still see a chance for Microsoft’s shiny new user interface.
What’s missing in Windows Phone 7 are features that were not included in some early version of the iPhone, or Android, namely copy/paste, multitasking or Adobe Flash support. Apple and Google however, had a couple of years head start to work on these issues, most of which are now solved. So is Windows Phone 7 offering too little too late? Here’s what the first reviews are saying.
PCWorld’s Ginny Mies spent some time with Windows Phone 7 devices, and thinks Microsoft has done “an excellent job” with the user interface, performance and functionality. However, Mies notes, the absence of features like copy/paste, third-party multitasking and Flash support “are big disappointments and set the OS behind both the Android and iPhone OSs.”
Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer introducing the new Windows Phone 7 devices. Credit: Microsoft
Wall Street Journal’s Walt Mossberg is also not convinced about Windows Phone 7: “Overall, I can’t recommend Windows Phone 7 as being on a par with iPhone or Android-at least not yet.” He notes in his review he “couldn’t find a killer innovation that would be likely to make iPhone or Android users envious,” and sees “Windows Phone 7 as inferior to iPhone and Android for most average users. It’s simply not fully baked yet.”
ComputerWorld’s Dan Rosenbaum thinks Microsoft did the right choice “in choosing between the simplicity and elegance of the iPhone and the power and deep configurability of Android, Microsoft has plainly (and perhaps surprisingly) opted for the former.” He says the new OS is “genuinely innovative, but whether you should buy it on Day One depends largely on your appetite for new things.”
Reviewing for Engadget, Joshua Topolsky writes that Windows Phone 7 “is a good year behind market leaders right now, and though it’s clear the folks in Redmond are doing everything they can to get this platform up to snuff, it’s also clear that they’re not there yet.” Despite this, “Microsoft has done an outstanding job with lots of aspects of this UI, particularly when it comes to navigation and ease of use — but there are holes here as well,” Topolsky notes.
CNet’s Bonnie Cha debates that “It’s absolutely mind-boggling that Windows Phone 7 is missing some very fundamental features, like copy/paste, third-party multitasking, and universal search.” She concludes that “Microsoft’s long road to a comeback won’t be an easy one, but at least it’s now headed down the right path.”
Gizmodo’s Matt Buchanan is much more impressed however: “Windows Phone 7 is really great. A solid foundation, it’s elegant and joyful. True, a lot of that greatness is potential. But if anybody can follow through on their platform, it’s Microsoft.” He avoids recommending it over an iPhone or Android device right now: “In six months, after the ecosystem has filled out, the answer will be more clear.”
Article from PC World: www.pcworld.com








Choosing a SmartPhone
ADAM TURNER – Sydney Morning Herald
Last updated 05:00 25/11/2010
The latest smartphones let you email, take photos and surf the web, all at the touch of a screen.
Today’s smartphones are smarter than ever. Just about anything you can do with a computer you can do on a smartphone and it also works as an in-car sat-nav. Oh, and you can make phone calls, too.
The latest smartphones are designed around sharp displays and slick touchscreen interfaces. Some say Apple’s iPhone 4 leads the way but others believe Android-powered rivals such as the HTC Desire HD and Samsung Galaxy S stand toe-to-toe with Apple’s wondergadget. Apple rules iPhone software with an iron fist, ensuring stability, while Android gives phone makers and users much more flexibility.
Microsoft’s clunky Windows Mobile phones are popular in the business world but have fallen out of favour since the rise of the iPhone. Microsoft fought back with the release of Windows Phone 7, a consumer-friendly touchscreen overhaul available on new phones such as the HTC Mozart, Samsung Omnia 7 and LG Optimus 7Q.
The Optimus 7Q is interesting in that it is one of the few new smartphones to feature a slide-out QWERTY keyboard. The trade-off is that it’s thicker and heavier than other smartphones. Most smartphones only feature an on-screen keyboard for entering text, often assisted by predictive text and auto-correct. On-screen keyboards are fine for bashing out quick messages but if you’re looking to do a lot of typing, then you might want to consider a smartphone with a slide-out physical keyboard.
The BlackBerry started off as a glorified pager but has also undergone a consumer-friendly makeover in recent years. The BlackBerry Torch 9800 is the first device in Australia to run the new touch-friendly BlackBerry 6.0 software. The Torch doesn’t have a physical QWERTY keyboard on the front – rather, the keyboard slides down from beneath the screen or you can use the on-screen keyboard. Other BlackBerry models include the Curve and Bold, with full QWERTY keyboards on the front, and the slim-line Pearl, which has a stripped-down keyboard.
Nokia’s E series phones, such as the E72, cater to business users, while its high-end N series phones, such as the N97, are targeted at consumers. While the N series phones are packed with features, the clunky Symbian S60 interface falls far short of the user experience offered by competing smartphones. Nokia attempted to remedy this with the release of the N8 smartphone, with its software revamp known as Symbian^3.
The N8 also features one of the best phone-based cameras on the market and includes impressive features such as HDMI video output. Unfortunately, the N8 has been praised for its features but canned over the cumbersome Symbian^3 interface. Nokia has indicated it intends to reserve Symbian^3 for its camera phones and switch to the coming Linux-based MeeGo operating system for its high-end smartphones.
What to look for
A smartphone should be judged as much on user experience as features. The success of the iPhone is proof of this. Android and BlackBerry have followed down this path, with Microsoft and Nokia chasing behind.
Some competitors have caught up with the iPhone in terms of usability but Apple still leads the way when it comes to the ecosystem, offering a vast range of applications via the iTunes App Store. Also, a wide range of accessories is available, including car kits and docking stations with built-in speakers.
Google’s Android Market has matured to the point where you’ll find apps to meet most of your needs but it still trails behind Apple. Also, some Android Market apps won’t run on the tiny Android phones with screen resolutions below 480 x 320.
BlackBerry, Nokia and Windows Phone 7 also have fledgling app stores. Unfortunately, old Windows Mobile apps won’t run on the new Windows Phone 7 devices. Nokia’s N8, powered by Symbian^3, will run old Symbian S60 apps but apps aren’t transferable between Nokia phones, so if you’re upgrading, you’ll need to buy all your apps again.
Article from www.stuff.co.nz